Jump to Navigation

Robinhood Plaza, Inc. et al. v. City Council, Jersey City, Unreported, Law Division 2015

The firm's client is developing 500 Summit Avenue, adjacent to the PATH Station at Journal Square in Jersey City. Litigation commenced on behalf of the client in 2010, alleging unequal and arbitrary mistreatment in rezoning its property. That litigation resulted in a settlement with the City, which called for amendment of the Journal Square 2060 Redevelopment Plan. That amendment gives Robinhood Plaza a height allowance, from 25 stories to 42 stories, in exchange for the dedication of some of its property for a public park, and other considerations. The City Council amended the Redevelopment Plan to conform to the changes in zoning but, after a municipal election, refused to implement a final step - vacating a small portion of a public street to conform to the Redevelopment Plan. On a motion to enforce litigant's rights, the trial judge concluded that the City could not use as a defense that a future governing body cannot be bound by its predecessor when the subject is implementation of a redevelopment plan, and that, in any case, "equitable estoppel" precluded the City from disavowing its contractual commitment to Robinhood Plaza. The court concluded that Robinhood Plaza suffered "manifest injustice" due to the voluntary conduct.

Business Law Advice in New Jersey
AV Lexis-Nexis Martindale-Hubbell Peer Review Rated for Ethical Standards and Legal AbilitySuper Lawyers

Kates Nussman Rapone Ellis & Farhi, LLP
190 Moore Street, Suite 306
Hackensack, NJ 07601
Phone: 201-488-7211
Fax: 201-488-1210
Map and Directions

Current News & Announcements
  • Supreme Court Ruling Legalizes Same-Sex Marriage Nationwide
    Michael Farhi addresses the Supreme Court ruling on Same-sex Marriage. Read More...
  • Michael Farhi Receives Preeminent Attorney Rating for 2015
    Michael Farhi is pleased and humbled to have received a Preeminent Attorney rating for 2015, giving him the "highest possible rating in both legal ability and ethical standards." Read More...
  • When Your Job Is Hazardous to Your Health
    Businesses are required under the federal Occupational Safety and Health Act (OSHA) to provide a safe working environment for their employees. Generally, OSHA protects all employees regardless of title or classification. But it does not protect those who are self-employed or who work for state or local government. New Jersey has its own laws that protect those employees. Read More...
  • Employment Discrimination - Watch What You Sign Or Be Out Of Time
    The New Jersey Supreme Court will review a lower court decision in a case called Rodriguez_v._Raymours_Furniture. There's a lot at stake for both employers and employees. Read More...
  • Consumer Protection or Business Extinction?
    The New Jersey State Assembly's Consumer Affairs Committee just cleared a bill that would have a drastic impact on contracts between businesses and consumers. The proposed law would ban contracts that force consumers to give up or limit certain rights, such as the right to sue, to bring a class action, to contact a law enforcement agency to file a consumer complaint, or to secure a jury trial. Read More...
  • FMLA Leave Will Apply to Same-Sex Spouses
    Following the wave of cultural and legal change, the U.S. Department of Labor's (DOL) Wage and Hour Division has ruled that all lawful same-sex spouses are recognized for purposes of FMLA leave, regardless of the couple's state of residence. This takes effect on March 27, 2015. Read More...
  • Recent Successes in Court - Published Decisions.
    Precedent-setting cases were published this year in favor of clients of Kates Nussman Rapone Ellis & Farhi in the fields of land use law and tax exemptions for clinical programs housing the mentally ill. Read More...